Creating a wishlist online: what is the difference?

Free online wishlist, no sign-up: add wishes from any shop, share one link – guests reserve gifts, nothing is bought twice, and who gives what stays secret.

Create one for free View an example

Free, no sign-up and no app.

An Amazon wishlist is quick to set up but ties everyone to one shop. A piece of paper or a WhatsApp message is flexible, but nobody sees what is already taken. Wish-Share combines both: wishes from any shop or without a link, one link for everyone, and guests reserve so nothing is bought twice.

The three options side by side

Criterion	Wish-Share	Amazon wishlist	Paper or WhatsApp
Account needed to create the list	No, just a title	Yes, an Amazon account	No
Do guests need an account?	No, opening the link is enough	Yes, to buy through Amazon	No
Wishes from different shops	Yes, a link from any shop	Mostly Amazon products	Yes, as text
Wishes without a link (an experience, something homemade, time)	Yes, as a free wish	Only as an idea without a product page	Yes
Guests reserve – nothing is bought twice	Yes, with one click, wherever the gift is bought	Purchases outside Amazon must be marked by the guest by hand	No, needs coordination
Who gives what stays secret	Yes, you only see “reserved”	Partly, depending on settings	No, people ask around
Group gifts (several guests, one gift)	Yes, for wishes from 150 euros	No	Only by arrangement
Your own design for the list	Yes, several backgrounds to choose from	No, Amazon's layout	On paper, yes
Independent of one shop, extendable later	Yes, at any time with wishes from other shops or without a link	No, tied to Amazon	Yes
Cost	Free, financed through partner links	Free	Free

Which one when?

Wish-Share: When family and friends buy in different shops, some wishes are not products at all, and nobody should have to create an account. Typical for Christmas, children's birthdays, babies and weddings. And even when everything is bought on Amazon anyway: you stay independent of one shop, choose the design of your list yourself, and if a wish from another store or one without a link comes along, it fits on the same list.
Amazon wishlist: When everyone involved already has an Amazon account and the list will never hold anything but Amazon products.
Paper or WhatsApp: When there are only two or three wishes and the givers coordinate among themselves anyway.

Frequently asked questions about wishlists

What is the difference between Wish-Share and the Amazon wishlist?

The Amazon wishlist belongs to an Amazon account and shows Amazon products. On Wish-Share you need no account, you can add wishes from any shop or with no link at all, and your guests reserve with one click – wherever they end up buying the gift.

Can I put Amazon products on my Wish-Share list?

Yes. The built-in product search finds Amazon products directly, or you paste the link. Wishes from every other shop fit on the same list.

How does the list reach my guests?

You get a link to share and send it by WhatsApp, e-mail or in the invitation. Whoever opens it sees the list in the browser – no app, no account.

Is Wish-Share worth it if everyone buys on Amazon anyway?

Yes. You stay independent of one shop, your guests need no Amazon account, you choose the design of your list yourself, and if a wish from another store or one with no link at all comes along later, it fits on the same list. You still find Amazon products with one click through the product search.

How does Wish-Share prevent duplicate gifts?

Every wish has a status. As soon as someone reserves a gift, everyone else sees “already taken” – and nobody buys the same thing twice.

Does it stay secret who gives what?

Yes. You see that a wish is reserved, but not by whom. The surprise lasts until the occasion.

Is Wish-Share really free?

Yes, permanently and without an account. Wish-Share is funded by partner links: if someone buys a gift through a shop link on your list, we may receive a small commission. The price stays exactly the same for you and your guests.